Recriminations 2012

It was a tough night. Much tougher than I expected. I was wrong, terribly, terribly wrong. Led astray by faulty premises and errant data. Gallup and Rasmussen found a country made up of either even numbers of Republicans and Democrats or more Republicans. I expected GOP enthusiasm to match that. It didn’t. Final exit polls make the national electorate look like D+6, only one point down from the D+7 in 2008.

If the GOP can’t do better than flipping two states (IN, NC) after four years of the most hated President in decades on the right, it’s got a lot of soul searching to do. Go moderate? Go libertarian? Go more socially conservative? I obviously have a preference there, but we don’t really know what the electorate will want in 4 years.

Some other quick takeaways:

  • GOP holds the House (and even pick up a few seats), Democrats hold the Senate. Gridlock goes on.
  • Obamacare and Dodd-Frank are now permanent law.
  • Mitt Romney is a great man who deserved better than this. I wish him all the best.
  • President Obama ran a hell of a campaign. Democrats should be congratulated.
  • We still desperately need tax reform, entitlement reform, and immigration reform. Those are all much less likely to happen now.
  • No one should blame third party candidates like Gary Johnson, even if his total is bigger than the margin in places like Florida. We don’t know where those votes would have gone, or if they would have shown up at all.
  • The 2016 GOP primary starts tomorrow.
  • The incredible WI-centrism of the GOP of the last two years (Priebus, Ryan, Johnson, Walker) was for naught.
  • Paul Ryan retains his House seat. Unclear if he retains his leadership within the party now.
  • Obama is the first candidate since FDR to win reelection with fewer electoral votes and states than his initial win.
  • I would say the auto bailout securing OH was the price we paid for Obama’s reelection, but that doesn’t explain FL, VA, IA, CO.

On to the next one…

    Gutcast 2012

    In the real world, polling is more art than science, otherwise we’d already know who was going to win the US Presidency next week. I’ve looked at lots of data over the last few months, seen ground reports, consulted my tea leaves and entrails, and here’s what I think we’ll see at the end of the day (or, god forbid, week or month):

    I think the polls are seriously overestimating Democrat turnout in their models, by between 2-8 points per state. The GOP base is more motivated to vote than they’ve been in 25 years. While I don’t think the map will look like it was back then (80, 84, 88) because of demographic changes, it damn well won’t look like 2008 either. Then-Candidate Obama was blessed by a convergence of a handful of factors that led to his big win last time. But there are lots of disappointed and disaffected people who voted for him who won’t again, and almost no one who didn’t vote for him last time who has been so convinced by his political prowess that they will now. His 2008 victory is his absolute ceiling. The tide has turned. 2010 was either a foreshadowing or the high point.
    On the off-chance that even I am underestimating GOP turnout, we could wake up to a massacre of this scale:

    But back down to earth (or below it, depending on your perspective)… If the polls are actually, miraculously right (they can’t all be, since they vary wildly), Obama will win, and it will look like this. A smaller margin than 2008 (ironic given most polls give his party a bigger share of the electorate), but still a decisive victory:
    If some of the more mid-line polls are right, but GOP turnout still improves, Romney might eek it out with a painfully small margin (for both legal challenges and political capital post-inauguration).

    I hope I’m right and we wake up on Wednesday to at least a 300 electoral vote win, so President Romney can get started in correcting our nation’s course without controversy. Anything less and we’re likely to see Florida 2000 in at least one state, probably more. The psychological damage to our republic would be more devastating than the last four years.